Mayo holds off John Marshall in a 93–88 dual meet thriller

Rochester Mayo and Rochester John Marshall traded blows through eleven events Thursday at a dual meet that never stretched beyond a 25-point gap and finished with Mayo on top, 93–88. John Marshall won five events to Mayo’s six and kept chipping away late, but Mayo built enough of a cushion through diving and the butterfly events to withstand the pressure. It was the kind of meet where every relay leg, every close split, and every underclassman scoring against older competition mattered.

200 Medley Relay

Mayo set the tone immediately. The relay of Elise Weingarten, Emelia Fischer, Halle Yuan, and Penelope Hauser touched in 1:55.88, 2.66 seconds clear of John Marshall’s squad of Kayla Mingo, Abigail Tri, Janet Njeru, and Karolina Palczewska at 1:58.54. Mayo also held the third spot through the relay of Celine Herrmann, Harper Mueller, Madalyn Viers, and Amelia Dean at 2:05.56, and because a team scores only two relays, Mayo banked 10 points to John Marshall’s 4 — an early 10–4 edge.

200 Freestyle

John Marshall answered right away. Freshman Eloise Bohn touched first in 2:09.52, holding off Mayo’s freshman Madalyn Viers by just 0.89 seconds — the closest winning margin of the entire meet. Viers finished at 2:10.41, and Mayo’s Amelia Dean added a third-place 2:18.40. John Marshall also scored at fourth through seventh-grader Lyric Berry and fifth through freshman Ashland Mett, giving the Rockets 9 points to Mayo’s 7 for the event. The Mayo lead shrank to four, 17–13.

200 IM

Mayo’s senior Elise Weingarten came right back with a dominant 200 IM win, touching in 2:20.91, 3.41 seconds ahead of John Marshall sophomore Madilyn Keller at 2:24.32. Mayo’s Harper Mueller and Amelia Dean claimed third and fourth, and John Marshall’s Kayla Mingo scored fifth. The 11–5 event split in Mayo’s favor swung the lead out to 10, 28–18.

50 Freestyle

John Marshall’s Abigail Tri delivered the sharpest individual win of the first half of the meet. The senior touched in 24.18, more than a second ahead of Mayo’s Halle Yuan at 25.58. Mayo’s Penelope Hauser and Beatriz Trabuco were separated by just 0.75 seconds at third and fourth — a tight pair of scoring swims for the Spartans. Even with Tri winning and John Marshall scoring fifth through Augusta Mett, Mayo’s depth at third and fourth netted the Spartans a 9–7 event split, nudging the lead to 12.

Running score: Rochester Mayo 37, Rochester John Marshall 25

Diving

Mayo swept the top three diving spots. Andrea Korol, a junior, won with 162.55 points, edging John Marshall’s freshman Piper Glandon at 158.95 — less than four points apart. Mayo’s Charity Gauthier and Kaylee Ballenger placed third and fourth, and seventh-grader Aria Ribikawskis of John Marshall scored fifth. The 11–5 event split extended Mayo’s lead to 18.

100 Butterfly

Halle Yuan, back in the water, made it two straight Mayo wins. The junior touched in 1:03.00 and was followed by Emelia Fischer at 1:06.72 — a Mayo 1-2 finish, the only one either team produced through the first eleven events. John Marshall’s Janet Njeru and Sara Tran picked up third and fourth, and freshman Amelia McGregor scored fifth for Mayo. The event split again ran 11–5 in Mayo’s favor — the third time that exact margin appeared on the night — and the lead swelled to 24, 59–35.

100 Freestyle

John Marshall’s Madilyn Keller answered with the event’s only sub-minute swim, touching in 59.80. Mayo’s Celine Herrmann was 1.29 seconds back at 1:01.09 for second. Freshman Karolina Palczewska put John Marshall at third with 1:03.53, and the gap between Mayo’s Dylan Raukar in fourth (1:06.48) and John Marshall’s Hannah Johns in fifth (1:07.06) was just 0.58 seconds — the tightest gap between any two placed swims in the meet. John Marshall’s 10–6 event win trimmed four off the margin, pulling them back to 20 down, 65–45.

500 Freestyle

Mayo’s Penelope Hauser took the 500 Free in 5:44.46, building nearly a five-second gap over John Marshall’s Eloise Bohn at 5:49.44. Freshman Hadley Lindquist came in third for Mayo at 6:08.26, and John Marshall’s Augusta Mett fourth at 6:57.49. The 9–6 event split for Mayo edged the lead back up to 23, 74–51.

200 Free Relay

Mayo’s relay of Halle Yuan, Elise Weingarten, Madalyn Viers, and Penelope Hauser touched in 1:45.31, 2.65 seconds clear of John Marshall’s top relay — Abigail Tri, Karolina Palczewska, Madilyn Keller, and Eloise Bohn — at 1:47.96. John Marshall also scored a second relay through Janet Njeru, Charlotte Rinnhofer, Lyric Berry, and Sara Tran at 2:08.95. The 8–6 event split moved Mayo out to a 25-point advantage.

Running score: Rochester Mayo 82, Rochester John Marshall 57

100 Backstroke

John Marshall’s Kayla Mingo, who opened the meet on the backstroke leg of the medley relay, came back to win the individual event in 1:06.13. Mayo’s Celine Herrmann was right behind at 1:07.40 — just 1.27 seconds back — and Harper Mueller added third at 1:13.61. John Marshall’s Charlotte Rinnhofer picked up fourth. The 8–7 event split narrowly favored John Marshall, trimming one point off the Mayo lead.

100 Breaststroke

Abigail Tri made it a two-win night individually, taking the 100 Breast in 1:10.34 — 3.30 seconds ahead of Mayo’s Emelia Fischer at 1:13.64. Seventh-grader Lyric Berry of John Marshall placed third with 1:23.81, scoring against a field of upperclassmen. John Marshall’s Karolina Palczewska added a fourth-place 1:27.44. The Rockets posted an 11–4 event split, their largest margin of the meet. Tri became the only swimmer on either side to win both her individual events on the night.

400 Free Relay

John Marshall’s relay of Kayla Mingo, Eloise Bohn, Lyric Berry, and Madilyn Keller finished first in 4:09.73. A second John Marshall relay — Charlotte Rinnhofer, Augusta Mett, Alexandra Wilkinson, and Hannah Johns — came in at 5:14.77, 65.04 seconds back, the largest gap between any two placed swims in the meet. Rochester Mayo also put two relays in the water: the group of Amelia Dean, Hadley Lindquist, Celine Herrmann, and Dylan Raukar went 4:19.28, and the relay of Marin Benscoter, Laiken Lindquist, Eliza Davis, and Amelia McGregor swam 5:02.30.

When the final whistle sounded, Mayo’s early relay strength, Korol’s diving win, and the back-to-back 11–5 splits through diving and the butterfly had done enough work to hold off a John Marshall squad that won five individual events and kept the lead within reach for most of the night. Final score: Rochester Mayo 93, Rochester John Marshall 88.